This is a static archive of our old forum. Most features inc files and downloads work but some links are now dead
Please refer to Our Website or our Facebook Groupfor latest info.

20% Rule

BFPCR committee members only
All committee business in here. Please move topics found in other areas if needed to here for committee to discuss
gcre
Licenced Driver
Licenced Driver
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:33 pm

20% Rule

Post by gcre »

As per email trail.

My tuppenth:

We can't suddenly change a rule just in case a team turns up with either a) significantly higher quality athletes or b) a car which somehow defies the laws of physics.

We can look at the rule again following this event if necessary.

However, on point b, we really are not comparing apples and apples here I think. Through the years we have had QAD, Crude, PTO and others try all sorts of things and some top guys competing. Like Croggy etc. But over an endurance pedal car race, whilst there have been huge wins (statistically moreso by GCR back in the day in less advanced kit) no one has yet been so far advanced that rules have had to be changed.

There's aerodynamics, rolling resistance and physique. Who's to say Croggy, in the Paul Davies car, wouldn't have averaged something amazing at Hillingdon?

Going back again to last year and Fards and Ian were fast in Apollos, but not as fast as Phil. Fards in the velomobile was faster, enough to make a difference, but in a 3 wheeler and not enough to write off a load of lower teams from points I think.

What is most important to me is whether the Quattro, or any new car, is safe, and complies with rules like turning circles, driver protection etc. The car still has to 'fit' 4 or 6 drivers, get round corners, race though 24 hours and undergo many pit stops and driver changes.

I'm not saying its not brilliant, but let's not assume it is so far away that we panic and start changing rules!
wsrt
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 11
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:06 pm

Re: 20% Rule

Post by wsrt »

We dont want to turn anyone away, fast or slow and the young drivers are the future of this sport. Saying that we lapped 3 cars at Wombwell before they had even completed their first lap. How do we make it safer and make the slower cars faster so they are don't become slow moving objects to avoid. On the first race the first 8 teams were averaging 3 times faster than the slowest car.
User avatar
AlanGoodman
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 424
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 9:13 am
Location: Hemel Hempstead
Team: Apollo Racing
Contact:

Re: 20% Rule

Post by AlanGoodman »

What if the 20% rule was applied per class rather than overall?
And how is the rule currently applied at Shenington where some cars stop overnight?
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: 20% Rule

Post by Jes@GCRE »

The requirement is reduced in proportion to the hours the teams are allowed to race.
(rule 2.1)
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: 20% Rule

Post by dralphs »

wsrt wrote:We dont want to turn anyone away, fast or slow and the young drivers are the future of this sport. Saying that we lapped 3 cars at Wombwell before they had even completed their first lap. How do we make it safer and make the slower cars faster so they are don't become slow moving objects to avoid. On the first race the first 8 teams were averaging 3 times faster than the slowest car.
Totally agree, we don't want to get into a F1 style qualifying situation where you have to be within 107% of the pole time to race unless the stewards allow you a free pass. That would kill off new entrants at a stroke.

Having said that maybe we could look at making slower cars more visible and identifiable as slower moving, and in poor visability request all cars show a red rear light, maybe one flashing led light F1 style rather than a full light set.
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
Confectionery
Provisional Driver
Provisional Driver
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:31 pm
Location: London
Team: Swebbelli Racing

Re: 20% Rule

Post by Confectionery »

I support the 20% rule being applied in each class.
Off the top of my head, this would remove the risk of teams who placed relatively well in a given age class being given no points because they were totally outclassed by the race lead.
It also would make Shenington more sensible from this point of view - rather than applying a slightly artificial scaling, you just have all the PC3/4 teams off for 6 hours so you just apply the rule of 20% of the lead PC3 (or 4) car.

Downsides I can think of are that if there was only one entry in a class, they could potentially do a single lap and then take home full points.
I kind of doubt anyone would do this (what's the point of getting yourself and your team and your kit and your car to a racetrack if that's all you plan to do?) but maybe to clarify this point, we could say that the 20% rule applies to the leader in your *age* class.
So for example, if Swebbelli entered a PC2(F) car, we would still have to get 20% of the lead PC2 car's laps in order to score any championship points in either PC2 or PCF.
There's also a possible argument to be made that this doesn't encourage slower cars to go faster...but I think it could be argued either way. It does increase the chances of a younger team getting points and being able to compete within their championship class, which I think is a good aim.

What do people think?
User avatar
Mark Williams
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 200
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
Location: East Yorkshire

Re: 20% Rule

Post by Mark Williams »

Can I ask a daft question... (Why) Do we need the 20% rule?
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: 20% Rule

Post by dralphs »

Mark Williams wrote:Can I ask a daft question... (Why) Do we need the 20% rule?
I assume to stop a "team" turning up to a race, doing 1 or a few laps and going home with at least 1 point, maybe more if there are PC3/4 teams below them.
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
wsrt
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 11
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:06 pm

Re: 20% Rule

Post by wsrt »

A few years ago Sharnbrook Scouts failed to do 20% of the leaders laps at Solihull. If they had been given the points it would have changed the results of the PC4 championship. Two years ago at Curborough, our car broke its steering not long into the race. If we didn't get the car fix we wouldn't have done the 20% laps, wouldn't have scored the points and lost the championship.

Before Steph started doing most of the races, it could have been possible for a female team to do 1 lap at each race and win the championship!!!

I don't know why we have the 20% rule but I do like it. As for the 24hr race, the PC3/4 teams miss 25% of the race. So in 75% they have to do 20% of the winners laps. If we look at last years Shenington results, last place team, 35th Oxford, didn't reach the 20% amount (failed by 9 laps). However if you took the number of laps 2nd from last did, the leaders would have to do more than 1145 laps. The winners did 733. So as long as the leaders average less than 30mph 2nd from last would have scored points. The winner would have to do an average of 35mph to stop 3rd from last scoring points.

If teams are averaging at 30mph, the 20% isn't the issue, it is the collision with slower cars which are doing 6 mph. I like the idea of always having a red flashing light on in poor visibility and maybe on all cars that are doing under 10mph. Race control could tell a team that when they next pit to switch on a rear red flashing light.
gcre
Licenced Driver
Licenced Driver
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:33 pm

Re: 20% Rule

Post by gcre »

Somehow one of my posts got a bit lost, but I queried whether the 20% wasn't for your specific class already? Or this is something which has been in, out, in etc over the years?

On the subject of very slow cars- this is something we momentarily battle with. If we want new blood we have to accept some slow starters. We don't want small, refined grids of just fast teams. However, there was that one howlin dog car where the poor lad couldn't reach the pedals!

Similarly, we have to politely educate new, very fast drivers, when then pot juniors into the pits accidentally. We need to retain these people too! ;)
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: 20% Rule

Post by Jes@GCRE »

I agree but it's even less than that because the 6 hours break is taken into account so in 18 hours they only have to do 15% of the winners laps.

Even if a car is doing 30mph, I don't think that a 6mph average speed is too much to ask to gain points in what is supposed to be a national championship.
wsrt
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 11
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:06 pm

Re: 20% Rule

Post by wsrt »

So back to the original question. Do we give a championship point to the last place car at Wombwell who didn't complete 20% of the laps. The rules say they get 0 points. In the past we have not awarded points to teams who have failed to achieve the magic 20% figure. I need a decision from the committee so the results can be uploaded
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: 20% Rule

Post by Jes@GCRE »

Null points
Confectionery
Provisional Driver
Provisional Driver
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:31 pm
Location: London
Team: Swebbelli Racing

Re: 20% Rule

Post by Confectionery »

I say we stick to the rules and don't give them points.
User avatar
Wing Racers
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2014 8:14 pm
Team: Wing Racers

Re: 20% Rule

Post by Wing Racers »

I think they should have a point, the 20% rule should be applied by class and a high vis rear light for the slower teams is a great idea...I will even order a load of rear lights from cycle division and give them FOC to the federation to hand out at the next race.
Wing Racers
______________________
2015 PC1 Champions