This is a static archive of our old forum. Most features inc files and downloads work but some links are now dead
Please refer to Our Website or our Facebook Groupfor latest info.

R2 PCD Trophies

BFPCR committee members only
All committee business in here. Please move topics found in other areas if needed to here for committee to discuss
User avatar
Mark Williams
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 200
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
Location: East Yorkshire

R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Mark Williams »

Well that was a bit of a balls up. Having looked back at the Finishing Positions I'm very sorry but I've managed to hand all the PCD trophies to the wrong teams.

For reference:

#59 Norton Greyhounds in effect ran as a duo but they had listed three on their Teamsheet and in the end Martin didn't manage to get to the circuit. #59 was not PCD.

#65 Doughty Racing joined the grid at the death after their Car completed scrutineering and was then parked up for the Drivers to complete their team sheet and hand to Race Control. Unfortunately, the Team sheet turned up during Hour 3 after several earlier requests. Whilst they then had the PCD listing on screen, it was considered inappropriate to allow their position as at the start of the race they weren't designated PCD. Hence my doubt as I started to read out the results that I'd wrongly written for the presentations.

So #55 was given 3rd, #12 was given 2nd, and in my further confusion #24 who had been in the battle all day went home with 1st.

Review the Finishing Screenshot again with the above and in my view the true result for PCD is:
3rd #24
2nd #55
1st #12

Any objections to putting this explanation up for public consumption ?
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
User avatar
AlanGoodman
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 424
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 9:13 am
Location: Hemel Hempstead
Team: Apollo Racing
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by AlanGoodman »

No objections!

No worries - I think you did a great job today as always Mark... These things are bound to happen from time to time when we get people switching classes at the last minute, and I doubt (hope) nobody is taking PCD seriously enough to lose any sleep over the trophies...
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by dralphs »

No Objections just let me know what caption on what photo :D

I've always thought it odd that results can be contested after the race and after trophies are awarded, although its obvious you can't present trophies when everyone has gone home.

I think in this case its quite obvious regarding 59 & 65 as rules state at the top under definitions that the TeamSheet must be submitted during Scrutineering and in 1.2 it states about points, number of drivers and teamsheets.

Maybe we need to reinforce the teamsheet rule at next race along with cars displaying correct class designations for PC0, PCF and ask PCD to display a Black D on white background.

Maybe need another rule that team managers must check lapcount display within first 30min and confirm all is correct.
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
User avatar
Wing Racers
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2014 8:14 pm
Team: Wing Racers

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Wing Racers »

No objections.
I was under the impression that a car would fail scrutineering without a completed team sheet.
We need to look at how we handle entries that arrive late, and whether we should make any allowances...
Wing Racers
______________________
2015 PC1 Champions
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by dralphs »

Mark. Please check gallery when you get chance to see if i've now got it all correct
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
User avatar
Mark Williams
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 200
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
Location: East Yorkshire

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Mark Williams »

All ok from what I've seen

Gareth,
is there anything else required to form the race result for the webpage and championship points list?

Dave,
Is the wombwell race result page not showing properly under the submenu? Text says results still to come ?!?
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by dralphs »

i need to rethink the wombwell results page, think we have a gareths' generic page and then a reports page(s)
But i'll look later/tomorrow
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
gcre
Licenced Driver
Licenced Driver
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:33 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by gcre »

Actually Mark, car 65 was not showing as PCD on the scores until about hour 5.. Its a tricky one because we know they were a duo.. but as Mark says in hindsight we know Norton were a duo and if they'd left handing in the team sheet until they knew their 3rd man wasn't arriving then they could have done the same!

However, on the other subject of lap scores... the AGM did agree the process for assessment and correction post race IF there is seen to be a genuine cause for complaint.

We are still investigating but presently I want to let you all know the manager of Car 1 and the manager of Car 4 are in discussion as to a possible reversal of position.. clearly this can only be undertaken under the strict application of the process set up at the AGM last year. It's important because it could have significant championship implications further down the road...

Meanwhile Apollo will be looking to reposition tags for the next race.. ;)
User avatar
AlanGoodman
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 424
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 9:13 am
Location: Hemel Hempstead
Team: Apollo Racing
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by AlanGoodman »

If car 4 wins at Shenington I'll be running naked down the pit lane singing zipperdy do-dah!
So there's an incentive for everyone else to get training. :D
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Jes@GCRE »

Mark,

It seems to me that some teams (and indeed some individuals!) made your life very difficult on Saturday and I hope we all appreciate the effort you put in to making these races run so smoothly.

Norton Greyhounds were definately not PCD if they handed in a team sheet with PC1 on it and I am really not sure if #65 should technically have been racing at all if they didn't hand a team sheet in until half way through - does this have any implications for insurance or anything? (Just asking).

I know we did have several new teams who hadn't realised they had to print off team sheets and therefore used up the stock of spares too. This is much more understandable than established teams not having them to hand.

J
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by dralphs »

AlanGoodman wrote:If car 4 wins at Shenington I'll be running naked down the pit lane singing zipperdy do-dah!
So there's an incentive for everyone else to get training. :D
I will make sure i have camera at the ready with the MACRO lens :o

Sadly won't be able to publish photos on gallery due to our under age drivers
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Jes@GCRE »

Well, if our analysis is correct (and our "protest" is upheld!) #4 and #1 will be practically level on points going into Shenington so we *could* just put all the fast guys in #4 now you have said that!
User avatar
AlanGoodman
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 424
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 9:13 am
Location: Hemel Hempstead
Team: Apollo Racing
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by AlanGoodman »

:D :lol:
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by dralphs »

As to saturdays results. Think you have to take what was entered on the teamsheet as submitted before start of race. It is then up to Team managers to confirm during practice that the timing screen is correct.
To me you can't change class after the race starts - unless the car details have been entered incorrectly on the screen due to an error on our part.

And #65 strictly under the rules wouldn't get any points as no teamsheet, they were allowed to race at discretion of race control pending submission of team-sheet.

I was too busy to take note of who was Scrutineering but assume it was gary?

Its clear in the rules, team-sheets to be presented at scrutineering, perhaps he can be asked to refuse to pass a car until team-sheet handed in (and we must support that). i know in the past I've had to run up to scrutineering to get a pass as i forgot to sign as team manager.
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
User avatar
Mark Williams
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 200
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
Location: East Yorkshire

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Mark Williams »

Having spoken to Steph, she was aware that Rob and Martin were running in #65 having spoken to Marc at Doughty before the race started.
Whether that helps or hinders this review I'm not sure since as people are aware the lack of team sheet from scrutineering is a Fed issue.

My annoyance is the fact that despite requests their team sheet turned up so late. As a point of note I haven't satisfied myself that they ticked the PC1 and PCD boxes on the form but I do remember Rob signed it as team manager for the benefit of insurances.

I'll come back on this tonight... Tbh I'm not sure Rob's view on this and of course this is visible to him as Committee...
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire