I think we should give them a little leeway.
From what i can see in the rules its 20% of laps overall in the round, not per race.
Now ok in race 2 they only did 1 lap but that could have been car trouble, and had we run race 3 they could have done 27 laps like they did in race 1 which added together would give them 55 laps overall more than meeting the 20%. (Assumes winners did 82 + 82 + 82 = 246 that puts 20% = 49.2)
For comparison, Bob last year did 34 + 14 + 6 + 8 total 62, winner of each race did 64 + 64 + 64 + 63 total 255
20% of 255 = 51 so Bob got his points but if you look at individual races (which isn't the rule) he only did 20% in race 1 & 2.
So should we penalise them for not being given the chance to make up the laps needed in race 3?
I think in this case they get the benefit of doubt and get the point, however had we run race 3 and they had still been under 20% then rule applies and no points.
This is a static archive of our old forum. Most features inc files and downloads work but some links are now dead
Please refer to Our Website or our Facebook Groupfor latest info.
Please refer to Our Website or our Facebook Groupfor latest info.
20% Rule
- AlanGoodman
- Site Admin

- Posts: 424
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 9:13 am
- Location: Hemel Hempstead
- Team: Apollo Racing
- Contact:
Re: 20% Rule
I agree with Dave...
Re: 20% Rule
This is fine, as long as you are happy that this sets a precedent and the same would be applied should Apollo, Wing, BAR or anyone else have a similar result in the future.
Re: 20% Rule
I disagree with going against the rule book, it will come back and bite us. The car did one lap at the beginning of race 2 and stopped. Had they kept going for the full 4 hours on a really bad car and missed out, then we may considered it. Other teams in the past have lost championships due to this rule. Sharnbrook Scouts failed to meet the 20% target at Solihull by 0.8 of a lap, didn't get the points, which allowed Wootton Scouts to win the title.
I think the rule is correct and if a team cant do 20% of the winners laps, it doesn't score points. We should only change this rule at the AGM, if the winners of PC1 are doing average speeds (over 30mph) that teams who are pedalling for the full race can't meet this target.
I think the rule is correct and if a team cant do 20% of the winners laps, it doesn't score points. We should only change this rule at the AGM, if the winners of PC1 are doing average speeds (over 30mph) that teams who are pedalling for the full race can't meet this target.
Re: 20% Rule
Absolutely
Also, I very much doubt this team will be discouraged from coming back when they find out they have missed out on 1 championship point.
They can't have done many fewer laps than BAR last year and no one was argueing that BAR should have been given points.
we set this up as a British Championship, not a scout type event where everyone gets a badge just for turning up.Jes@GCRE wrote:Null points
Also, I very much doubt this team will be discouraged from coming back when they find out they have missed out on 1 championship point.
They can't have done many fewer laps than BAR last year and no one was argueing that BAR should have been given points.
- dralphs
- Site Admin

- Posts: 553
- Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
- Location: Oxford
- Team: Falcon Notnray
- Contact:
Re: 20% Rule
BAR did 19 laps last year, winner was 255 which gives 51 for 20% so well under. In any case BAR withdrew.
I think on reflection our hands are tied with rules as they stand, they didn't do 20% so no points.
However we need to revisit this at AGM to clarify what the 20% (or other percentage) means and what happens if we get this situation again where a team does very few laps in one race of a multi-race round.
I think on reflection our hands are tied with rules as they stand, they didn't do 20% so no points.
However we need to revisit this at AGM to clarify what the 20% (or other percentage) means and what happens if we get this situation again where a team does very few laps in one race of a multi-race round.
- Mark Williams
- Site Admin

- Posts: 200
- Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
- Location: East Yorkshire
Re: 20% Rule
Just trying to put a response down... give me 5mins to justify them having their point...
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
- Mark Williams
- Site Admin

- Posts: 200
- Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
- Location: East Yorkshire
Re: 20% Rule
I'm not sure if this has been finalised but I want to itemise this out if I may.
Lead Car raced a total of 164 laps over the shortened event.
20% Rule equals 32.8 laps over the shortened event.
Car #49 only competed 28 laps over the shortened event therefore in theory under past and present reading of the Rulebook for completion of entire events, they should not receive any Championship points.
However, since the Event was curtailed early by Race Control, removing the third Race and the opportunity to reach the entire race 20% threshold, I would suggest at the discretion of Race Control to allow the point to stand given the extenuating circumstances of the day.
For further reference:
2.1. Qualification for Championship Points
a) A team will qualify for championship points in each class in which it meets the class@ qualification criteria if it completes over 20% of the laps achieved by the overall winner of that round. This minimum requirement is reduced proportionally in the case of teams prevented from racing an entire event due to their class.
Theoretically, if #49 had completed another five laps during Race 2 with all others score as was, they would have completed 33 laps to cross the 20% event threshold. In that situation, past and present reading of the Rulebook would allow them to receive their point irrespective of the fact they would have only completed 6 laps in Race 2 with the Lead Car completing 82 laps in Race 2.
Current reading does not set the 20% rule individually to the split races. It would be silly to do so - the scenario of a Race 1 mechanical that could knock a car out temporarily with then no championship points to fight for in running in Race 2 or Race 3. If it were a single 6 hour race, they would conceivably repair the car and return to aim at the 20% threshold and then some. The split race competition should not be disadvantaged just because the event has parts. Hence the current rule for an entire event is absolutely valid for this season and beyond.
Lead Car raced a total of 164 laps over the shortened event.
20% Rule equals 32.8 laps over the shortened event.
Car #49 only competed 28 laps over the shortened event therefore in theory under past and present reading of the Rulebook for completion of entire events, they should not receive any Championship points.
However, since the Event was curtailed early by Race Control, removing the third Race and the opportunity to reach the entire race 20% threshold, I would suggest at the discretion of Race Control to allow the point to stand given the extenuating circumstances of the day.
For further reference:
2.1. Qualification for Championship Points
a) A team will qualify for championship points in each class in which it meets the class@ qualification criteria if it completes over 20% of the laps achieved by the overall winner of that round. This minimum requirement is reduced proportionally in the case of teams prevented from racing an entire event due to their class.
Theoretically, if #49 had completed another five laps during Race 2 with all others score as was, they would have completed 33 laps to cross the 20% event threshold. In that situation, past and present reading of the Rulebook would allow them to receive their point irrespective of the fact they would have only completed 6 laps in Race 2 with the Lead Car completing 82 laps in Race 2.
Current reading does not set the 20% rule individually to the split races. It would be silly to do so - the scenario of a Race 1 mechanical that could knock a car out temporarily with then no championship points to fight for in running in Race 2 or Race 3. If it were a single 6 hour race, they would conceivably repair the car and return to aim at the 20% threshold and then some. The split race competition should not be disadvantaged just because the event has parts. Hence the current rule for an entire event is absolutely valid for this season and beyond.
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
Re: 20% Rule
Mark I think you are totally right. Should have thought of this before. It was exception and it is potentially a valid strategy (albeit an odd on) to focus on the last race. Particularly as the event was curtailed only after all racing had, as it happened, ended for the day I don't think the 20% rule can be upheld in this case.
Re: 20% Rule
If the car had mechanical problems and was out for race 2 and being worked on, and was fixed ready for race 3, then I can see there being a valid objection by the team. It would have meant race 1 - 27 laps, race 2 - 1 lap, race 3 - 22 laps and was potentially possible.
The reality is the car was parked on the grass for the entire race and no maintenance was being done. Changing a rule after the season has started can backfire on us. we are talking about one PC1 point, six, PC2 points and ten PC3 points.
The reality is the car was parked on the grass for the entire race and no maintenance was being done. Changing a rule after the season has started can backfire on us. we are talking about one PC1 point, six, PC2 points and ten PC3 points.

