This is a static archive of our old forum. Most features inc files and downloads work but some links are now dead
Please refer to Our Website or our Facebook Groupfor latest info.

R2 PCD Trophies

BFPCR committee members only
All committee business in here. Please move topics found in other areas if needed to here for committee to discuss
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Jes@GCRE »

[quote="Mark Williams"]My annoyance is the fact that despite requests their team sheet turned up so late. As a point of note I haven't satisfied myself that they ticked the PC1 and PCD boxes on the form but I do remember Rob signed it as team manager for the benefit of insurances. [quote]

Thats good of Marc but he really needed to tell you!
gcre
Licenced Driver
Licenced Driver
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:33 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by gcre »

Does anyone know what happened to the no-shows on Saturday. Just for future reference why they didn't take part. Was it Matrix?
gcre
Licenced Driver
Licenced Driver
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:33 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by gcre »

sorry scrap that. It was Bob, our #9 and Boreatton which someone did tell me..
User avatar
Mark Williams
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 200
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
Location: East Yorkshire

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Mark Williams »

PC1 and PCD ticked in line with what we knew...
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
gcre
Licenced Driver
Licenced Driver
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:33 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by gcre »

ApolloLapsBruntingthorpe2015.xlsx
(85.65 KiB) Downloaded 92 times
Here is my request for adjustment. Please see the attached sheet. I want to re-iterate that the process we introduced last AGM does NOT mean we the committee or anyone is beholden to check every result every time. You all know that I do this for our cars anyway for other purposes and also I was always a little concerned about #4's laps, but as I was fully involved in #1 had no basis for specifics on the day.

Secondly, its important to state that in no way are Phil / Mark at fault here. It was a busy day and the actual timing issue was dealt with very well. Also I've known our tags aren't in the best place for a while and hold my hand up that I meant to change this and didn't get round to it.

So I firmly believe that Car 4 completed a lap more than Car 1 on the day and that had 1 known it was two laps further behind following our wheel failure it is highly unlikely that we would have made that extra lap up for the place - we were going full-chat the whole race to be honest and car 4 would have known it had more to defend against too. In my view there is almost no doubt about this because pit stop laps were no where near double the length of racing laps. Our guys were all pretty consistent, and when we had the long stop for the wheel change I know we didn't drop any laps because the sequence of #4's pit stop and line-crosses are consistent.

This change is important because it could have significant Championship implications later on - especially given how close it was with Apollo and Wing last year. All Apollo I think accepts this result should be changed.

Jacob has also independently checked this data and arrived at the same conclusion.

Secondarily, I also checked through Wing - because for parity 1 and 4 were net gaining laps. Wing I think also should have an extra lap - which changes little - but of course I can't say if this was a long pit stop or something. I believe that pretty much everyone dropped one lap more than was accounted for during the counting failure - but clearly this would not change any results.

I hope this is OK and now leave it in the hands of the committee.. I am more than happy for this change to be made for the publication of the 'provisional' result rather than confusing it later.

It certainly spices things up a bit more with 3 teams within 6 points!!
User avatar
AlanGoodman
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 424
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 9:13 am
Location: Hemel Hempstead
Team: Apollo Racing
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by AlanGoodman »

Many thanks to Chris for the time and effort he has put into this, and for his honesty!!!
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Jes@GCRE »

Are we in a position to post the provisional result please?

J
User avatar
Wing Racers
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2014 8:14 pm
Team: Wing Racers

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Wing Racers »

Chris, having looked through you data I would agree with your findings. If your team is happy with these findings then all okay with me.
It does looks like we dropped another lap as well, I asked my guys whether we had an extra long pitstop, the only one that was a bit slower than normal was the last change due to having to rip the rear wheel cover off.
I need to check the position of our tag as well, it might be a bit higher than 3" off the deck.
Maybe we should call St Chris of Apollo now. :D
Wing Racers
______________________
2015 PC1 Champions
gcre
Licenced Driver
Licenced Driver
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:33 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by gcre »

Not really. :oops: I am a man of several hats.. I always had a feeling that #4 was further back than it felt was right - they were on good form.

so I make the top three:

Wing: 386
Apollo 4: 375
Apollo 1: 374

That make sense?

Where are we with the PCD? Should all parties agree between themselves? And if that means #65 is PCD due to a form submitted after 4 hours should #59 also be invited because everyone 'knows' they were only a duo also? Its a tricky one.. :?
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Jes@GCRE »

#59 submitted a form categorically saying they were not PCD so that's easy, they aren't.

#65 didn't submit a team sheet until half way through the race. So you could argue they weren't anything!
User avatar
Mark Williams
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 200
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
Location: East Yorkshire

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Mark Williams »

Just had comments of Gary H on email. I paraphrase but
'Team 105 #24 were in the midst of racing #12 and #55 as designated for fives hours so it was a surprise when #65 finally popped up as PCD. We had no chance to deal with the deficit in an hour'

I can't do anything other than agree with that sentiment so I would return to the earlier statement that #65 cannot earn points due to the lack of a teamsheet at the start of the race.
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
User avatar
Mark Williams
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 200
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 6:58 pm
Location: East Yorkshire

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Mark Williams »

Gary #59 was happy in their circumstance of not being PCD. They were too happy racing...

Still don't know the views of Rob #65
Mark
BFPCR Treasurer
East Yorkshire
Jes@GCRE
Pedalcar racer
Pedalcar racer
Posts: 522
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:34 pm

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Jes@GCRE »

Mark Williams wrote:Just had comments of Gary H on email. I paraphrase but
'Team 105 #24 were in the midst of racing #12 and #55 as designated for fives hours so it was a surprise when #65 finally popped up as PCD. We had no chance to deal with the deficit in an hour'

I can't do anything other than agree with that sentiment so I would return to the earlier statement that #65 cannot earn points due to the lack of a teamsheet at the start of the race.
I didn't see said earlier statement but I agree with it.
User avatar
dralphs
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 553
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2014 11:50 pm
Location: Oxford
Team: Falcon Notnray
Contact:

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by dralphs »

I'm happy with changes to the top 3 PC1
As to PCD, agree #59 said weren't PCD on teamsheet so it must stand as not PCD
#65 to me only raced at discretion of mark as no teamsheet until several hours in so can't get any points at all.
Dave
Falcon Notnray Racing
www.yarntonscouts.org.uk
Confectionery
Provisional Driver
Provisional Driver
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2014 11:31 pm
Location: London
Team: Swebbelli Racing

Re: R2 PCD Trophies

Post by Confectionery »

In my view, these changes are all fair.